Tag Archive: Naomi Klein


Fascism – the sequel

END TIMES FASCISM AND THE FIGHT FOR THE LIVING WORLD by Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor ( Allen Lane, 2026)

The American Heritage Dictionary states that‘fascism’ is  “a system of government marked by centralization of authority under a dictator, a capitalist economy subject to stringent governmental controls, violent suppression of the opposition, and typically a policy of belligerent nationalism and racism.”

Based on this definition it is hard to argue that Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor are wholly wrong to label narcissitic megalomaniacs, religious zealots and techno-titans as fascists. But, at the same time, the strong association linking fascism with the Nazi-driven holocaust makes it a term that should be used with extreme caution. Klein and Taylor write “we were looking for a re-run, what we got was a sequel” as a recognition that what happened in the past does not follow a smooth narrative line into the present.

Fascism is often elevated into something more akin to a political philosophy than purely as a ‘system of government.’ To my mind, the warped ideas of tyrannical leaders like Hitler and Mussolini are aberrations better confined to history rather than being in any way ennobled or resuscitated. The influence of these despots stands as a sobering illustration of mankind’s capacity to be led into the depths of depraved thoughts and deeds.

To ascribe any philosophical label to the distorted visions of the current breed of power-driven individuals implies that there is more method than madness at the heart of their thoughts and actions. Yet it is the notable absence of guiding principles or morality that makes them so scary and dangerous.

In many interviews I have seen Naomi Klein has been asked to justify the use of the F word. In one with Louis Theroux she argues that to focus too much on definitions can distract from what the march of the far right means for ‘ordinary’ people and our vulnerable planet. One way to avoid getting bogged down with semantics is to avoid using contentious terminology in the first place. ‘Fascism’ is such a loaded and so over-used a word that it is probably best avoided. No amount of qualification will eliminate the baggage that comes with it. There are other ways of describing the acceleration of mess we are in.

None of this is to diminish the precious contribution Klein and Taylor are making with this book and their tireless campaigning. They are to be applauded for diligently trying to make some sense of the confusing times we are living through. ‘End of Times Fascism’ is essential reading and a bold attempt to document fast-moving events with the aim of alerting readers to the urgent need for at least slowing down the more obvious excesses in order to avert a full-blown apocalypse.

As someone who fears the tipping point may have already passed, I read this book seeking to assuage feelings of despondency or fatalism. The alternative to a search for ways to fight back and/or reasons for hope is to give in to despair and passivity. Klein and Taylor provide a valuable reminder that resistance is never useless.

EMPIRE OF AI : Dreams and Nightmares in Sam Altman’s AI by Karen Hao (Penguin Books, 2018)

“AI can only exist by devouring the totality of the world’s information and then the world itself.” – Shoshana Zuboff

What began as a trickle has become a deluge. The AI tsunami is now a seemingly unstoppable force. We are drowning in its effects. Open AI started as a non-profit altruistic initiative but has morphed into something that produces enormous benefits to the wealthy elite whilst exploiting and depriving the rest of civilization.

While smaller AI models are more likely to improve health care and education or to potentially slow down the impact of climate change, the danger now is that most seem to believe that bigger is automatically better. At the root of the problem is the fact that what is good for society is not necessarily good for business. Sam Altman’s holy grail of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) for all is now blithely defined as “highly autonomous systems that outperform humans at most economically valuable work.”  So much for the benefits to mankind!

During an interview with Naomi Klein, Hao commented that, when she began writing her monumental book,  the feelings towards all the latest technological breakthroughs were more likely to be positive. By the time the work was published after conducting over 300 interviews, the mood has shifted and her underlying scepticism towards its potential benefits is now widely shared. Part of this fear lies in the unknown. As Hao writes: “Technology’s advancement is headed towards an unknown objective, with no foreseeable end in sight.”  

While reading this book, I was constantly struck by the thought that the full consequences of what is being unleashed has not been fully thought through. Take for example the term “iterative deployment” which refers to the way imperfect models are released into the public domain despite it being known that there being many unresolved issues. The reasoning is that any adjustments can be made later based on user experience and feedback. We are the guinea pigs in other words.  In the case of  ChatGPT, this means that, prior to corrective measures,  ‘conversations’ are much more likely to include negative stereotypes relating to gender, race and faith.

Continue reading →
Naomi Klein & Astra Taylor

In pre-internet days ‘The End Of The World Is Nigh’ was the warning slogan of religious nutcases on many city high streets.

I imagine nowadays there are plentiful versions of the same message to be found in social networks. For the most part these placard-carrying, rapture-dreaming, doom-mongers of the past were harmless enough and dismissed as objects of ridicule.

Given the state of the planet right now, maybe it’s time to wonder whether they were onto something after all.

The thrust of  ‘The Rise of End of Times Fascism’ by Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor certainly supports the view that the end of days are closer than ever.  These two women warriors’ have studied the rise of the far right in Trump’s America and come to the conclusion that “the most powerful people in the world are preparing for the end of the world.” 

Taylor is a new name to me but I hold Klein in such high esteem that I know she is not one to make such a dramatic claim without good reason. If anyone can be trusted to fact check it is her. Watch her eloquently  explain her treatise in measured tones in a short interview for Democracy Now to understand that she is not bent on scaremongering without just cause. The evidence she and Taylor put forward is both comprehensively damning and scary as shit.

Their thesis is as simple as it is chilling. The end times are a logical and pre-planned conclusion to the capitalist model which so brazenly divides the world into winners and losers.  The super wealthy have built their fortresses and bunkers knowing that catastrophes are the inevitable consequences of the policies Trump-Musk and their allies are pursuing so cynically. As Klein and Taylor write “The forces we are up against have made peace with mass death. They are treasonous to this world and its human and non-human inhabitants.” 

The scale of the task to turn this around is huge. I’m sure am not alone in constantly feeling that it is insurmountable.  But if there is a takeaway from Klein’s recent mind-expanding dialogue with ANOHNI, it is that we cannot let hope die without a fight. We cannot allow AI to replace human creativity, or stand by and accept that profits come before morality.  If we do either then the end truly is nigh.

Going into specifics about what action can and should be taken is not easy. Klein and Taylor don’t have all the answers but they are sure as hell posing the right questions. I am full of admiration for their courage in raising their heads above the parapet. Their rallying cry may be vague but it is an urgent one:  “we will need to build an unruly open-hearted movement of the Earth-loving faithful.”  

Sign me up.  

As individuals we can save water, ride bikes and use energy-saving lightbulbs but even if everyone diligently did all these things the problem would not go away.

Today the cities were full of people marching to demand action to prevent global warming. A good thing of course. It prompted TV news stations to dust off their stock footage of ‘natural’ disasters and smog-filled cities.

Animal agriculture is the number one cause of climate change, a fact that governments and businesses have kept quiet for obvious reasons. To make matters worse, Al Gore, Greenpeace, Naomi Klein and other campaigners have also all but ignored this issue.

If you are truly worried about climate change then you should watch Cowspiracy and check out the Green Your Diet website.

Going vegan is the ideal solution but even reducing the consumption of meat would help the planet far more than turning off unnecessary lights or not using water sprinklers on your lawn.

THIS CHANGES EVERYTHING by Naomi Klein (Allen Lane, 2013)

“It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends on his not understanding” – Upton Sinclair.

Alternative titles to this brave and important book could have been ‘Everything Must Change’, ‘Everything is Fucked’ or even more despairingly, The End Is Nigh.

Whatever way you look at the situation that Naomi Klein presents, it is clear that humanity is well and truly up shit creek climate-wise.

It would nice to report that this book also provides us with some metaphorical paddles but, sadly, this is not the case.

Klein presents the scale of the problem but in terms of solutions ultimately offers only a faith in the essential resilience of the human spirit. Continue reading →