OPEN EDUCATION : REFLECTIONS ON LEARNING NETWORKS
"I never teach my pupils: I only attempt to provide the conditions in which they can learn" - Albert Einstein.
One of the effects of the abundance of online learning resources is the trend of coming up with new terms to define what we mean by education and even to question what its purpose is.
There are still relics of the Dickensian notion that students are vessels to be filled facts but, thankfully, this is a pedagogy that by and large belongs to the past.
Yet, although we like to think we live in a more enlightened age, the rapid nature of the change over the past two decades continues to be hard to assimilate.
Openness implies accessibility and an accommodating attitude so, all things being equal, these should be good times for teachers and students, life-long or otherwise.
So why do I feel so much doubt and uncertainty? Shouldn’t my mood be more celebratory?
In George Siemens and Stephen Downes’ theory of Connectivism, the assertion is that knowledge can be gained by the ‘nodes’ within the plethera of social network sites.
But, even when these nodes are connected, an autonomous Personal Learning Environment (PLE) can still be a sad place to be unless there is also some meaningful contact with the outside world.
I have a strong anti-social streak in me, but even I can appreciate that without face to face contact with peers, the effect will be anything but liberating.
In The Challenges of Connectivist Learning, Rita Kemp write that “participation in activities is seen as being vital to learning”. This may seem like a mundane observation until you consider the difference between participation in a ‘real’ classroom environment and that which takes place online.
By blogging, tweeting, posting on Facebook walls or commenting on other posts we are making connections but I constantly ask myself how much I am learning from these activities.
Often they make me feel more disconnected as I note how many people appear more learned than me and how they lead lives which frequently seem more dynamic and interesting than my own.
I didn’t start writing this post with any clear idea where it would take me.
It has led me to these melancholy thoughts – maybe I need to get out and network more!
Related articles
- Must Be Something in the PLE. (kgreenshields.wordpress.com)
- eLearning – Personal Learning Environments (sh20121930.wordpress.com)
- E-learning (nd20121811.wordpress.com)









Hi Martin, Thank you for this personal insight. I agree a PLE and PLN can feel a little like a one man band sometimes, especially if no one is leaving a comment; giving you a like; favouriting or retweeting a tweet. ( Who’d have thought 20 years ago I’d be writing a sentence like that.) I think we have to analyze for ourselves why we choose to set up these virtual connections as the answer will be different for many of us. Is it for learning or professional purposes; to promote a business; for self-reflection and archiving of our own resources for easier access, or for social contact etc? If it’s solely the latter then we’ve really got to get ourselves out in the real world as well. I don’t think we need to be put off by those who appear to be ‘knowledgeable others’, take what you can from them, be brave and engage in dialogue. I receive few comments on my blog but can see that the statistics tell another story. So someone is dropping in and doing a bit of scanning and skimming, perhaps even taking home a few ideas to work with and that’s fine with me, I blog for other reasons.
Regarding learning from the connections I suppose it’s about how actively you’re engaging with the resources that others share and whether you can get involved in some discussions. That’s where G+ is quite good. Keep an eye out for Hangouts with live streaming.
Trish
Thanks for those kind words, Trish. Much appreciated.
I’ll look out for the Hangouts!
Martin
Martin,
Congratulate yourself on your willingness to blog and share your thoughts. We probably all feel a bit inadequate, some days more than others. There are those in this course who are very clear, concise writers and I am not one of them, so I end up blogging less, but apart from feeling like an inadequate writer and getting panicky when I feel like I have to, I learn a lot from reading and commenting on others writing. like yours
Thank you for giving me the freedom for expressing my feeling on the subject.
Thanks for the moral support, Deborah – I must say you sound clear and concise enough to me 🙂
Hi Martin, thanks for sharing your thoughts. I don’t think a PLN has to be only virtual – that can as you say be a bit of a lonely place. Synchronous classrooms environments such as BB Collaborate or Google Hangouts can help bridge the chasm a bit. My best interactions have been meeting people face to face that I first met online either via Twitter, blogs or Facebook and then continuing that connection using social media tools. It’s also great when meeting someone face to face and then continuing online – sounds like I am talking about a Blended PLN? Of course, this is rare but lovely when it happens.
Thanks Sukaina, I agree that PLNS can be both virtual and ‘real’. Living in Italy, I don’t get much chance to meet and discuss these issues offline so the social networks you mention are my lifeline. On the whole, these are great but there are also some days when I feel like a gadget. The PLN post was one of those days! 🙂 It’s good to hear your positive experiences to set this into proper perspective.
Martin