Tag Archive: Roger Ebert


JACQUE TATI’S CIRCLE GAME

PLAYTIME directed by Jacques Tati (France, 1967)

With all the plate glass windows in this movie it’s only a matter of time before someone mistakes one for an open doorway. It’s a gag waiting to happen but Jacques Tati is more interested in taunting the audience and playing with their expectations than giving them the payoff too quickly.

He also does this by having other actors adopt the Monsieur Hulot look of half mast trousers, suede shoes, Argyle socks, beige mac, trilby hat , pipe and umbrella. This leads to several instances of mistaken identity while the real Hulot is confined to something akin to a cameo role.

This reflects the fact that Tati was feeling boxed in by the success of his popular creation. Rather than rest on his laurels, he wanted his comedy to be more challenging.

He therefore dispenses with a predictable storyline in favour of a movie where the theme of  modernity is in lieu of any actual plot. As in Mon Oncle, sophisticated technology is shown as making relatively simple tasks more complicated and only serve to create more barriers to meaningful communication.

The result of  Tati’s adoption of a more experimental approach in Playtime is a movie that was posthumously hailed as a masterpiece but all but bankrupted him during his lifetime. The paying public failed to be sufficiently impressed by the elaborate sets, which came to be known as ‘Tativille’, or the meticulously choreographed scenes. They came to the cinema to be entertained and left feeling cheated. Continue reading

A FEEL GOOD USHER

A nice initiative in my local town (Cesena) was to have a film night with selected piazzas and other open air venues given over to free movies and cinema talks. I chose to see Jean Epstein’s 1928 silent film of Edgar Allan Poe’s ‘The Fall of the House of Usher (La Chute de la maison Usher).

One reason was because I had never seen it, although I have since discovered that  you can see the movie at the Internet archive.

The other reason was  that I was intrigued by the fact that there was a live soundtrack by a three-piece Bolognese rock band Massimo Volume.

This was probably a one-off commission but they did a great job bringing out the gothic drama and not trying to impose their style on the film . Their soundtrack was certainly an improvement on the medieval music by Rolande de Cande which you hear on the online version.

The fim itself retains its gothic power and creates a surreal world of its own (helped in part by contribution of Luis Bunuel).

Jean Debucourt  as Roderick Usher has mesmerising eyes that make him look either mad or high on some illicit substance. Madeline flops about in a distracted state. She  is his wife in the movie (she was his sister in Poe’s short story) and for some reason Epstein decided on a feel good ending where they both survive the destruction of the house. It would have made more sense for them to be consumed within the crumbling mansion but perhaps even in 1928 the general public didn’t like to see the protagonists meeting a sticky end.

Related link:
Review on Roger Ebert’s Great Movies